Ultimate Guide to Choosing Your Ideal Key West Hotels

Vanessa Korovina
1 month ago

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of hotels in Key West, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
Pier House Resort & Spa

8.1 / 10

(627 Reviews)

From 471$
Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa

8.2 / 10

(619 Reviews)

From 608$
Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel

5.6 / 10

(332 Reviews)

From 440$
Sunset Key Cottages

9.2 / 10

(108 Reviews)

From 760$
The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection

8.4 / 10

(37 Reviews)

From 459$

Nestled at the southernmost tip of the United States, Key West beckons travelers with its clear turquoise waters, vibrant street scenes, and a laid-back attitude that embodies the essence of island living. Among the myriad attractions, finding the perfect stay at one of the many Key West hotels enhances the experience, immersing visitors in the charm and hospitality that this island paradise is renowned for. The right accommodation becomes a gateway to the island's treasures, from sun-kissed beaches to historic haunts that echo the tales of pirates and poets.

Key West's eclectic mix of accommodations means there's something to suit every taste and budget, from luxurious beachfront resorts to quaint, boutique hotels steeped in the island's rich history. Recommendations often highlight the importance of selecting a hotel that not only offers comfort and amenities but also reflects the unique spirit of Key West. With a carefully chosen hotel, travelers can look forward to waking up to breathtaking ocean views, relaxing in serene gardens, or stepping out directly into the heart of Old Town's vibrant nightlife and cultural offerings.

Embarking on the journey to find the ideal Key West hotel involves tapping into local insights and considering what facets of the island's lifestyle you wish to experience. Whether it's the allure of waking to a stunning sunrise over the Atlantic, the convenience of being steps away from Duval Street's lively scene, or the peace of a secluded retreat, Key West's hotels play a pivotal role in crafting unforgettable memories. This article aims to guide you through the captivating world of Key West accommodations, ensuring your stay is nothing short of magical.

Table of contents

Pier House Resort & Spa Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa Luxury Key West Hotels for an Opulent Stay Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel Sunset Key Cottages Beachfront Key West Hotels for Seaside Bliss The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection

View all photos

8.1
Very good
627 Reviews

Pier House Resort & Spa

📍 One Duval Street

From 471$

Pier House Resort & Spa, another gem among Key West hotels, offers a luxurious beachfront stay combined with rich cultural history. Positioned at the edge of Old Town, the resort provides guests with direct access to its private white sandy beach and a view of the clear blue waters. The rooms and suites are elegantly furnished, creating a cozy yet upscale ambiance. The resort's spa is a sanctuary of wellness, offering a range of treatments inspired by the island's natural beauty. Dining options include the renowned Beach Bar and Grille, where guests can enjoy fresh local cuisine with an ocean view. Pier House Resort & Spa is a fusion of luxury, culture, and relaxation, embodying the best of Key West's beachfront accommodations.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Luxury Key West Hotels for an Opulent Stay

For those seeking indulgence and unparalleled luxury in their Key West stay, this section delves into the upper echelon of Key West hotels. These establishments are not merely places to sleep; they are gateways to opulence, offering sumptuous accommodations, exquisite dining, and breathtaking views. Here, every detail is meticulously curated to ensure an unforgettable experience. From private beaches and world-class spas to gourmet restaurants, these luxury hotels encapsulate the essence of extravagance. The selections in this category cater to the discerning traveler looking to immerse themselves in the unparalleled beauty and sophistication of Key West. Embrace the lavish lifestyle offered by these prestigious accommodations, where every desire is met with exceptional service.

View all photos

8.2
Very good
619 Reviews

Hyatt Centric Key West Resort & Spa

📍 601 Front Street

From 608$

The Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa offers a modern beachfront retreat in the heart of Key West. This resort caters to guests who seek both adventure and relaxation, with amenities designed to enhance the Key West experience. The rooms are decorated in a contemporary style, with private balconies offering panoramic sea views. The resort features an outdoor pool, a world-class spa, and water sports facilities for guests looking to explore the sea. The on-site restaurant, SHOR American Seafood Grill, serves up fresh catches and local flavors in an exquisite waterfront setting. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa captures the essence of a laid-back beach getaway while providing the luxury and service synonymous with the Hyatt brand.
Check Availability
Add to compare

View all photos

5.6
Good
332 Reviews

Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection By Hilton Hotel

📍 1500 Reynolds Street

From 440$

Casa Marina Key West, a stunning representation of Key West's luxury hotels, stands as a beacon of elegance and sophistication. Nestled on the largest private beach in Key West, this iconic resort, established in the 1920s, seamlessly combines contemporary luxury with historical charm. Guests can indulge in ocean-view rooms that offer a serene retreat, beautifully juxtaposed against the vibrant energy of Key West. The resort boasts two oceanfront pools, an on-site spa offering rejuvenating treatments, and water sports for the adventurous soul. Dining at the resort's flagship restaurant presents a culinary journey, with fresh seafood and local ingredients taking center stage. Casa Marina not only provides opulence but also serves as an emblem of Key West's rich tapestry of history and luxury hospitality.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Beachfront Key West Hotels for Seaside Bliss

Key West's allure is undeniably tied to its stunning ocean vistas and sandy shores. The beachfront hotels of Key West are not just accommodations; they are gateways to the island's breathtaking natural beauty. In this section, we explore hotels that offer direct beach access, allowing guests to step out of their rooms and onto the soft sands, under the warm Floridian sun. These establishments offer a diverse range of amenities from casual beachside bars to sophisticated dining with ocean views, catering to all who dream of waking up to the sound of waves. Whether it's a family vacation or a romantic getaway, these beachfront hotels encapsulate the quintessential Key West beach experience.

View all photos

9.2
Excellent
108 Reviews

Sunset Key Cottages

📍 245 Front St

From 760$

A short ferry ride from Key West offers an exclusive escape on a secluded 27-acre island. This luxury resort personifies the essence of Key West elegance and tranquility. Each cottage, whether it's a cozy one-bedroom or a spacious four-bedroom, offers breathtaking ocean views, gourmet kitchens, and plush amenities. Guests can dine al fresco at the resort's acclaimed restaurant, Latitudes, where the menu features fresh seafood and locally inspired dishes against a backdrop of stunning sunsets. The private beaches, tropical gardens, and an inviting pool create a haven of relaxation. Sunset Key Cottages represents the pinnacle of luxury Key West hotels, where privacy, beauty, and pampering converge to create an unparalleled island experience.
Check Availability
Add to compare

View all photos

8.4
Very good
37 Reviews

The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection

📍 417 Eaton Street

From 459$

Positioned in the heart of Old Town, The Saint Hotel brings a slice of modern luxury to the historical backdrop of Key West. This boutique hotel, part of the prestigious Autograph Collection, distinguishes itself with a blend of contemporary design and sultry sophistication. Each room and suite is meticulously appointed, offering a sanctuary of comfort with a touch of whimsy. The hotel is renowned for its captivating blue-hued pool, an oasis that promises solace and escape. On-site amenities include a vibrant bar and lounge where signature cocktails and live music create a lively social scene. The Saint Hotel redefines the luxury hotel experience in Key West, offering an unparalleled stay that is as unique as the island itself.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Location